2018-06-02T16:46:36.969-04:00 ERROR [WhoisIpLookup] Could not lookup WHOIS information for [159.66.236.64] at [ARIN].
2018-06-02T16:46:36.970-04:00 ERROR [WhoisIpLookup] Could not lookup WHOIS information for [138.68.46.177] at [ARIN].
Did you checked if the WHOIS lookup is working from the command line from your Graylog server?
It might be blocked by any firewall that is between the Graylog server and the WHOIS Server of ARIN. Or you have been ratelimited because of an overuse. That would be indicated by the logfiles.
Without providing this information we are not able to look that up and you need to find out and investigate on your own.