How many indices were there in the beginning with the testing retention settings?
I suggest you check that and if you need to keep those indices, use number of indices 184 + nr of test indices. When it is 6 months from the start of the new retention settings, you can change the max number of indices back to 184.
How many indices are currently in the index set you’ve configured the mentioned rotation strategy for?
If it’s less than 184, everything is working as expected and Graylog will automatically delete indices once there are more than 184 indices in that index set.
If you don’t want to wait until the automatic rotation kicks in, you can manually delete all indices you don’t want to keep.